Brett Gardner has never played for another team, but the Yankees. He’s a free agent this off season and the Yankees should try and work through his $12.5 M option, and keep him in Pinstripes in 2019. Gardner hit .236 with a .322 on-base percentage, and can still play at a high level in the outfield. Plus, he’s a fan favorite who understands his role. Yankee’s have a lot of tough free agent decisions to make this off-season, but keeping Gardner shouldn’t be one of them.