Better 2012 Season: Eli Or Romo?

As he opened "The Noe Show" today, Brian Noe took issue with how some guys get a pass just because of their previous success, while others get hammered. The example he used was Ben Roethlisberger's awful interception in the opening possession of overtime against the Dallas Cowboys, and how Dallas quarterback Tony Romo would have been getting killed if he threw that pass. This leads to an interesting question to test your true objectivity: who has had the better 2012 regular season, Tony Romo or Eli Manning?