New York Yankees
 
- Aaron Judge, 99: All Rise
- Gary Sanchez, 24: Kraken
- Brett Gardner, 11: Gardner
- Starlin Castro, 14: All-Starlin
- Dellin Betances, 68: D. Dawg
- Luis Severino, 40: Sevy
- Masahiro Tanaka, 19: Masa
- Aroldis Chapman, 54: The Missile
- Didi Gregorius, 18: Sir Didi
- Clint Frazier, 77: Red Thunder
Austin Romine, 27: Ro
- Adam Warren, 43: Rocket
- Chase Headley, 12: Head
- Jacoby Ellsbury, 22: Chief
- Chad Green, 57: Greeny
- Luis Cessa, 85: Quique
- Aaron Hicks, 21: A-A Ron
- Michael Pineda, 35: Big Mike
- Sonny Gray, 55: Pickles
- David Robertson, 30: D-Rob
- Greg Bird, 33: Bird
- CC Sabathia, 52: Dub
- Jaime Garcia, 34: J Gar
- Matt Holliday, 17: Holliday
- Todd Frazier, 29: Toddfather
- Jordan Montgomery, 47: Monty
- Ronald Torreyes, 74: Toe
New York Mets
- Noah Syndergaard, 34: Thor
- Matt Harvey, 33: Harv
- Zack Wheeler, 45: Wheels
- Jacob deGrom, 48: Jake
- Yoenis Cespedes, 52: La Potencia
- Jay Bruce, 19: Bruuuce
- Steven Matz, 32: Reno
- Jose Reyes, 7: La Melaza
- Michael Conforto, 30: Scooter
- Curtis Granderson, 3: Grandyman
- Wilmer Flores, 4: Catire
- Juan Lagares, 12: Angelo
- Neil Walker, 20: Walkie
- Rene Rivera, 44: Moncho
- Paul Sewald, 51: Paulie
- Josh Edgin, 66: Edge
- AJ Ramos, 40: Junior
- Travis d'Arnaud, 18: Lil D
- Tommy Milone, 29: Milone
- Rafael Montero, 50: Fugarra
- Robert Gsellman, 65: G-Man
- Seth Lugo, 67: Quarterrican
- Matt Reynolds, 15: Rey Rey
- Jeurys Familia, 27: La Fama
- David Wright, 5: D-Dub
- Fernando Salas, 59: Ferny
- Asdrubal Cabrera, 13: Chiquitín
- Jerry Blevins, 39: Gordo
- Hansel Robles, 47: El Peñaco
- Josh Smoker, 49: Brown Bear
- T.J. Rivera, 54: T-Butta
- Brandon Nimmo, 9: Nimms
- Erik Goeddel, 62: Goopy