Both Joe Dimaggio and Thurman Munson had great rookie seaosns for the New York Yankees but their stats do not compare to Alonso's. Joe Namath and Lawrence Taylor are the closest with LT helping the Giants back to the playoffs.

As for Aaron Judge, the New York athlete's he broke here are how their stats compare

Aaron Judge: 284 batting average 52 home runs 114 RBIs 24 doubles 9 stolen bases 208 strikeouts

Pete Alonso .260  batting average 53 home runs 120 RBIs 30 doubles 1 stolen bases 181 strike outs

Is Pete Alonso having the greatest rookie season in New York  history? Let us know below.